SEC10: How do you anticipate, respond to, and recover from incidents?

Preparation is critical to timely and effective investigation, response to, and recovery from security incidents to help minimize disruption to your organization. Even with extremely mature preventive and detective controls, your organization should still prepare for security incidents. Architecture decisions and day-to-day operations are informed by your preparation for incident response. Having the right people, processes, and technology in place before an incident occurs will help you reduce the time to recovery and minimize business impact.

Best Practices Overview

This question includes the following best practices:

Detailed Best Practice Descriptions

SEC10-BP01: Identify key personnel and external resources

Establish and maintain an incident response team with clearly defined roles and responsibilities. Identify internal team members, external partners, legal counsel, and regulatory contacts who will be involved in incident response. Ensure contact information is current and accessible during incidents.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Incident response team structure and roles
  • 24/7 contact information and escalation procedures
  • External partner and vendor relationships
  • Legal and regulatory contact management
  • Cross-training and backup personnel identification

SEC10-BP02: Develop incident management plans

Create comprehensive incident response plans that define procedures for different types of security incidents. Plans should include incident classification, response procedures, communication protocols, and recovery steps.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Incident classification and severity frameworks
  • Response procedures and playbooks
  • Communication and escalation plans
  • Recovery and business continuity procedures
  • Regular plan updates and maintenance

SEC10-BP03: Prepare forensic capabilities

Establish forensic investigation capabilities to support incident analysis and evidence collection. This includes deploying forensic tools, establishing evidence handling procedures, and maintaining chain of custody processes.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Forensic tool deployment and configuration
  • Evidence collection and preservation procedures
  • Chain of custody and legal requirements
  • Forensic analysis and reporting capabilities
  • Integration with legal and compliance teams

SEC10-BP04: Automate containment capability

Implement automated systems to quickly contain security incidents and limit their impact. Automation reduces response time and ensures consistent containment actions across different incident types.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Automated isolation and quarantine systems
  • Network segmentation and access controls
  • Automated threat response workflows
  • Integration with security tools and SIEM systems
  • Containment validation and monitoring

SEC10-BP05: Pre-provision access

Ensure incident response team members have appropriate access to systems and resources needed during incident response. Pre-provisioned access reduces response time and eliminates access delays during critical incidents.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Emergency access procedures and break-glass accounts
  • Role-based access controls for incident response
  • Secure access to critical systems and data
  • Access logging and monitoring during incidents
  • Regular access reviews and updates

SEC10-BP06: Pre-deploy tools

Deploy and configure incident response tools before incidents occur. Having tools ready and tested reduces response time and ensures responders have the capabilities they need when incidents happen.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Security monitoring and analysis tools
  • Incident tracking and case management systems
  • Communication and collaboration platforms
  • Forensic and investigation tools
  • Automation and orchestration platforms

SEC10-BP07: Run game days

Conduct regular incident response exercises and simulations to test procedures, train team members, and identify improvement opportunities. Game days help ensure readiness and effectiveness of incident response capabilities.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Tabletop exercises and scenario planning
  • Technical simulations and red team exercises
  • Cross-functional coordination testing
  • Communication and escalation drills
  • Post-exercise analysis and improvement planning

SEC10-BP08: Establish a framework for learning from incidents

Create systematic processes for learning from security incidents to improve future response capabilities. This includes post-incident reviews, root cause analysis, lessons learned documentation, and continuous improvement processes.

Key Implementation Areas:

  • Post-incident review processes and templates
  • Root cause analysis methodologies
  • Lessons learned documentation and sharing
  • Improvement action tracking and implementation
  • Learning effectiveness measurement and metrics

Key Concepts

Incident Response Fundamentals

Preparation: Establish the foundation for effective incident response through planning, training, tool deployment, and process development. Preparation activities occur before incidents happen and are critical for successful response.

Detection and Analysis: Quickly identify security incidents and assess their scope, impact, and severity. Effective detection relies on comprehensive monitoring, alerting, and analysis capabilities.

Containment, Eradication, and Recovery: Limit the impact of incidents, remove threats from the environment, and restore normal operations. These activities require coordinated response and well-defined procedures.

Post-Incident Activities: Learn from incidents through thorough analysis, documentation, and process improvement. Post-incident activities help strengthen future incident response capabilities.

Incident Response Lifecycle

Phase 1 - Preparation: Develop policies, procedures, and capabilities needed for effective incident response. This includes team formation, training, tool deployment, and communication planning.

Phase 2 - Detection and Analysis: Identify potential security incidents through monitoring and analysis. Determine if events constitute actual incidents and assess their severity and impact.

Phase 3 - Containment, Eradication, and Recovery: Take immediate action to limit incident impact, remove threats, and restore affected systems to normal operation.

Phase 4 - Post-Incident Activity: Conduct lessons learned sessions, update procedures, and implement improvements based on incident experience.

AWS Services to Consider

AWS Security Hub

Provides a comprehensive view of your security state in AWS and helps you check your compliance with security standards. Centralizes security findings for incident analysis and response coordination.

Amazon GuardDuty

Provides intelligent threat detection for your AWS accounts and workloads. Automatically detects malicious activity and provides detailed findings for incident response teams.

AWS Systems Manager

Gives you visibility and control of your infrastructure on AWS. Provides automation capabilities for incident response, including remote access and automated remediation.

AWS Lambda

Lets you run code without provisioning or managing servers. Enables automated incident response workflows and custom response actions based on security events.

Amazon EventBridge

A serverless event bus that makes it easy to connect applications together. Orchestrates incident response workflows and automates response actions across multiple services.

AWS CloudFormation

Gives you an easy way to model a collection of related AWS and third-party resources. Enables rapid deployment of incident response infrastructure and recovery environments.

Implementation Roadmap

Phase 1: Foundation and Planning (Months 1-3)

Objective: Establish the basic incident response foundation

Best Practices to Implement:

  • SEC10-BP01: Identify key personnel and external resources
  • SEC10-BP02: Develop incident management plans

Key Activities:

  1. Form incident response team and define roles
  2. Develop initial incident response procedures
  3. Establish communication and escalation plans
  4. Create incident classification framework
  5. Identify external partners and legal resources

Success Criteria:

  • Incident response team established with defined roles
  • Basic incident response procedures documented
  • Communication plans tested and validated
  • External partner agreements in place

Phase 2: Capabilities and Tools (Months 4-6)

Objective: Deploy technical capabilities and tools

Best Practices to Implement:

  • SEC10-BP03: Prepare forensic capabilities
  • SEC10-BP05: Pre-provision access
  • SEC10-BP06: Pre-deploy tools

Key Activities:

  1. Deploy forensic and investigation tools
  2. Establish evidence collection procedures
  3. Configure emergency access and break-glass accounts
  4. Deploy incident tracking and case management systems
  5. Set up monitoring and alerting infrastructure

Success Criteria:

  • Forensic tools deployed and tested
  • Emergency access procedures established
  • Incident response tools configured and ready
  • Monitoring and alerting systems operational

Phase 3: Automation and Integration (Months 7-9)

Objective: Implement automation and integrate systems

Best Practices to Implement:

  • SEC10-BP04: Automate containment capability

Key Activities:

  1. Develop automated containment workflows
  2. Integrate security tools and SIEM systems
  3. Implement automated threat response capabilities
  4. Configure network segmentation and isolation
  5. Test automation workflows and procedures

Success Criteria:

  • Automated containment systems operational
  • Security tool integration completed
  • Automated workflows tested and validated
  • Response time objectives met

Phase 4: Testing and Continuous Improvement (Months 10-12)

Objective: Validate capabilities and establish continuous improvement

Best Practices to Implement:

  • SEC10-BP07: Run game days
  • SEC10-BP08: Establish a framework for learning from incidents

Key Activities:

  1. Conduct tabletop exercises and simulations
  2. Perform technical incident response drills
  3. Establish post-incident review processes
  4. Implement lessons learned tracking
  5. Create continuous improvement workflows

Success Criteria:

  • Regular exercise program established
  • Post-incident review process operational
  • Lessons learned system implemented
  • Continuous improvement metrics tracked

Integration Architecture

Incident Response Technology Stack

Incident Response Workflow Integration

Maturity Assessment Framework

Level 1: Initial (Ad Hoc Response)

Characteristics:

  • Manual incident response processes
  • Limited documentation and procedures
  • Reactive approach to incidents
  • Inconsistent response quality

Key Gaps:

  • Lack of formal incident response plan
  • No defined team structure or roles
  • Limited tools and automation
  • Minimal post-incident analysis

Improvement Focus:

  • Establish basic incident response procedures
  • Form incident response team
  • Document initial response workflows
  • Implement basic monitoring and alerting

Level 2: Managed (Documented Response)

Characteristics:

  • Documented incident response procedures
  • Established incident response team
  • Basic tools and monitoring in place
  • Regular training and exercises

Key Capabilities:

  • Formal incident response plan
  • Defined roles and responsibilities
  • Basic automation and tools
  • Post-incident review process

Improvement Focus:

  • Enhance automation capabilities
  • Improve tool integration
  • Expand exercise program
  • Strengthen forensic capabilities

Level 3: Defined (Integrated Response)

Characteristics:

  • Integrated incident response platform
  • Automated detection and response
  • Comprehensive forensic capabilities
  • Regular exercises and improvement

Key Capabilities:

  • Automated containment and response
  • Integrated security tool stack
  • Advanced forensic and investigation tools
  • Systematic lessons learned process

Improvement Focus:

  • Optimize automation workflows
  • Enhance predictive capabilities
  • Improve cross-team coordination
  • Expand threat intelligence integration

Level 4: Quantitatively Managed (Measured Response)

Characteristics:

  • Metrics-driven incident response
  • Predictive threat analysis
  • Optimized automation workflows
  • Continuous improvement culture

Key Capabilities:

  • Advanced analytics and metrics
  • Predictive incident modeling
  • Optimized response procedures
  • Proactive threat hunting

Improvement Focus:

  • Implement AI/ML capabilities
  • Enhance predictive analytics
  • Optimize resource allocation
  • Expand automation coverage

Level 5: Optimizing (Adaptive Response)

Characteristics:

  • AI/ML-powered threat detection
  • Self-healing and adaptive systems
  • Predictive incident prevention
  • Industry-leading capabilities

Key Capabilities:

  • Autonomous threat response
  • Predictive incident prevention
  • Self-optimizing systems
  • Continuous innovation

Improvement Focus:

  • Research emerging technologies
  • Share best practices with industry
  • Contribute to security community
  • Drive innovation in incident response

Incident Response Architecture

Incident Response Workflow

Automated Response Integration

Incident Response Team Structure

Incident Response Framework

Incident Classification Levels

Severity 1 - Critical:

  • Significant business impact or data breach
  • Active compromise of critical systems
  • Regulatory notification requirements
  • Executive leadership involvement required

Severity 2 - High:

  • Moderate business impact
  • Potential system compromise
  • Significant security control failures
  • Management notification required

Severity 3 - Medium:

  • Limited business impact
  • Security policy violations
  • Suspicious activity requiring investigation
  • Team lead notification required

Severity 4 - Low:

  • Minimal business impact
  • Minor security events
  • Informational findings
  • Standard monitoring and tracking

Response Time Objectives

Critical Incidents (Severity 1):

  • Initial Response: 15 minutes
  • Containment: 1 hour
  • Communication: 30 minutes
  • Recovery Planning: 2 hours

High Incidents (Severity 2):

  • Initial Response: 1 hour
  • Containment: 4 hours
  • Communication: 1 hour
  • Recovery Planning: 8 hours

Medium/Low Incidents (Severity 3-4):

  • Initial Response: 4-24 hours
  • Containment: 24-72 hours
  • Communication: As required
  • Recovery Planning: As required

Common Challenges and Solutions

Challenge: Lack of Incident Response Preparedness

Solution: Develop comprehensive incident response plans, conduct regular training and exercises, establish clear roles and responsibilities, and maintain up-to-date contact information and procedures.

Challenge: Slow Incident Detection and Response

Solution: Implement automated monitoring and alerting, use machine learning for threat detection, establish 24/7 security operations capabilities, and create automated response workflows.

Challenge: Inadequate Forensic Capabilities

Solution: Pre-deploy forensic tools and capabilities, establish evidence collection procedures, maintain chain of custody processes, and develop relationships with external forensic experts.

Challenge: Poor Communication During Incidents

Solution: Develop communication templates and procedures, establish clear escalation paths, implement automated notification systems, and practice communication during exercises.

Challenge: Insufficient Recovery Capabilities

Solution: Implement automated backup and recovery systems, maintain recovery environment templates, establish recovery time objectives, and regularly test recovery procedures.

Incident Response Maturity Levels

Level 1: Basic Response

  • Manual incident response processes
  • Limited detection and monitoring capabilities
  • Reactive approach to incident management
  • Basic documentation and communication procedures

Level 2: Managed Response

  • Documented incident response procedures
  • Automated detection and alerting systems
  • Established incident response team and roles
  • Regular training and exercise programs

Level 3: Advanced Response

  • Automated response and containment capabilities
  • Integrated threat intelligence and analysis
  • Proactive threat hunting and detection
  • Comprehensive forensic and recovery capabilities

Level 4: Optimized Response

  • AI/ML-powered threat detection and response
  • Fully automated response orchestration
  • Predictive incident analysis and prevention
  • Continuous improvement and optimization

Incident Response Best Practices

Preparation and Planning:

  1. Develop Comprehensive Plans: Create detailed incident response procedures and playbooks
  2. Establish Clear Roles: Define responsibilities for incident response team members
  3. Regular Training: Conduct ongoing training and skill development programs
  4. Exercise and Testing: Perform regular incident response exercises and simulations
  5. Tool Deployment: Pre-deploy and configure incident response tools and technologies

Detection and Analysis:

  1. Comprehensive Monitoring: Implement monitoring across all systems and networks
  2. Automated Detection: Use machine learning and behavioral analysis for threat detection
  3. Rapid Triage: Establish efficient incident classification and prioritization processes
  4. Threat Intelligence: Integrate external threat intelligence for enhanced analysis
  5. Documentation: Maintain detailed records of all incident response activities

Response and Recovery:

  1. Rapid Containment: Implement automated containment capabilities where possible
  2. Evidence Preservation: Maintain proper chain of custody for forensic evidence
  3. Coordinated Response: Ensure effective coordination between response team members
  4. Recovery Planning: Develop and test recovery procedures for critical systems
  5. Communication: Maintain clear and timely communication with all stakeholders

Success Metrics and KPIs

Preparedness Metrics (SEC10-BP01, BP02, BP03, BP05, BP06)

Team Readiness:

  • Incident response team member availability (Target: >95%)
  • Contact information accuracy and currency (Target: 100%)
  • Training completion rate (Target: 100% annually)
  • Exercise participation rate (Target: >90%)

Plan and Procedure Effectiveness:

  • Incident response plan currency (Target: Updated quarterly)
  • Procedure adherence rate during incidents (Target: >95%)
  • Plan accessibility during incidents (Target: <2 minutes to access)
  • External partner response time (Target: <30 minutes)

Tool and Access Readiness:

  • Tool availability and uptime (Target: >99.9%)
  • Emergency access validation success rate (Target: 100%)
  • Forensic tool deployment completeness (Target: 100%)
  • Pre-deployed tool effectiveness score (Target: >8/10)

Response Effectiveness Metrics (SEC10-BP04)

Detection and Response Times:

  • Mean Time to Detect (MTTD) (Target: <15 minutes for critical)
  • Mean Time to Respond (MTTR) (Target: <30 minutes for critical)
  • Mean Time to Contain (MTTC) (Target: <1 hour for critical)
  • Mean Time to Recover (MTTR) (Target: <4 hours for critical)

Automation Effectiveness:

  • Automated containment success rate (Target: >95%)
  • False positive rate for automated actions (Target: <5%)
  • Manual intervention requirement rate (Target: <10%)
  • Automation workflow completion time (Target: <5 minutes)

Learning and Improvement Metrics (SEC10-BP07, BP08)

Exercise and Training Effectiveness:

  • Exercise completion rate (Target: Monthly for critical scenarios)
  • Exercise objective achievement rate (Target: >90%)
  • Identified improvement implementation rate (Target: >95%)
  • Team confidence and readiness scores (Target: >8/10)

Continuous Improvement:

  • Post-incident review completion rate (Target: 100%)
  • Lessons learned implementation rate (Target: >90%)
  • Repeat incident rate (Target: <5%)
  • Improvement action completion time (Target: <30 days)

Overall Program Effectiveness

Business Impact Metrics:

  • Incident business impact reduction (Target: 20% year-over-year)
  • Customer impact duration (Target: <2 hours)
  • Regulatory compliance maintenance (Target: 100%)
  • Incident cost reduction (Target: 15% year-over-year)

Stakeholder Satisfaction:

  • Executive leadership confidence score (Target: >8/10)
  • Business unit satisfaction with response (Target: >8/10)
  • Customer satisfaction during incidents (Target: >7/10)
  • Regulatory relationship quality score (Target: >8/10)

Common Implementation Challenges and Solutions

Challenge 1: Resource Constraints and Competing Priorities

Problem: Limited budget, personnel, or time to implement comprehensive incident response capabilities.

Solutions:

  • Phased Implementation: Use the roadmap approach to spread implementation over time
  • Automation Focus: Prioritize automation to reduce manual effort requirements
  • Shared Resources: Leverage existing security tools and personnel across multiple functions
  • Cloud Services: Use managed AWS services to reduce infrastructure overhead
  • Risk-Based Prioritization: Focus on highest-risk scenarios and critical business functions

Challenge 2: Lack of Executive Support and Buy-In

Problem: Insufficient leadership support for incident response investments and initiatives.

Solutions:

  • Business Case Development: Quantify risks and potential business impact of inadequate response
  • Regulatory Requirements: Highlight compliance and regulatory obligations
  • Industry Benchmarking: Compare capabilities with industry peers and standards
  • Success Stories: Share examples of successful incident response and cost avoidance
  • Regular Reporting: Provide visibility into program progress and effectiveness

Challenge 3: Siloed Teams and Poor Coordination

Problem: Lack of coordination between security, IT operations, legal, and business teams.

Solutions:

  • Cross-Functional Teams: Include representatives from all relevant functions
  • Clear Roles and Responsibilities: Define specific roles for each team and individual
  • Regular Communication: Establish regular meetings and communication channels
  • Shared Tools and Platforms: Use common incident management and communication tools
  • Joint Training and Exercises: Conduct exercises that involve all relevant teams

Challenge 4: Technology Integration and Complexity

Problem: Difficulty integrating multiple security tools and managing complex technology stacks.

Solutions:

  • Standardized APIs: Use tools and services with standard APIs and integration capabilities
  • Orchestration Platforms: Implement security orchestration and automated response (SOAR) platforms
  • Cloud-Native Services: Leverage AWS native services for better integration
  • Gradual Integration: Implement integrations incrementally rather than all at once
  • Documentation and Training: Maintain comprehensive documentation and provide technical training

Challenge 5: Skills Gaps and Training Needs

Problem: Insufficient skills and expertise within the incident response team.

Solutions:

  • Training Programs: Implement comprehensive training and certification programs
  • External Partnerships: Establish relationships with external experts and consultants
  • Knowledge Sharing: Create internal knowledge sharing and mentoring programs
  • Industry Participation: Participate in industry groups and information sharing organizations
  • Continuous Learning: Encourage ongoing education and skill development

Integration with Other Security Pillars

SEC01 - Identity and Access Management

  • Integration Points: Emergency access procedures, identity verification during incidents
  • Shared Capabilities: Break-glass accounts, privileged access management
  • Coordination Requirements: Identity team involvement in access-related incidents

SEC02 - Detective Controls

  • Integration Points: Security monitoring, threat detection, log analysis
  • Shared Capabilities: SIEM systems, security analytics, threat intelligence
  • Coordination Requirements: SOC and incident response team coordination

SEC03 - Infrastructure Protection

  • Integration Points: Network isolation, system hardening, vulnerability management
  • Shared Capabilities: Network segmentation, security controls, patch management
  • Coordination Requirements: Infrastructure team involvement in containment actions

SEC04 - Data Protection

  • Integration Points: Data classification, encryption, data loss prevention
  • Shared Capabilities: Data backup and recovery, encryption key management
  • Coordination Requirements: Data protection team involvement in data breach incidents

SEC05 - Application Security

  • Integration Points: Application vulnerability response, secure development practices
  • Shared Capabilities: Application security testing, code analysis
  • Coordination Requirements: Development team involvement in application security incidents

Regulatory and Compliance Alignment

GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation)

  • Requirements: 72-hour breach notification, data subject notification
  • Implementation: Automated notification workflows, data impact assessment procedures
  • Documentation: Incident records, response actions, notification evidence

HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act)

  • Requirements: Risk assessment, workforce training, incident documentation
  • Implementation: Healthcare-specific incident procedures, PHI handling protocols
  • Documentation: Security incident log, risk assessments, corrective actions

PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard)

  • Requirements: Incident response plan, forensic investigation, card brand notification
  • Implementation: Payment-specific incident procedures, forensic capabilities
  • Documentation: Incident response plan, investigation reports, remediation evidence

SOX (Sarbanes-Oxley Act)

  • Requirements: Internal controls, financial reporting integrity, audit trails
  • Implementation: Financial system incident procedures, audit trail preservation
  • Documentation: Control effectiveness evidence, incident impact assessments

Industry-Specific Regulations

  • Financial Services: FFIEC guidelines, regulatory examination requirements
  • Healthcare: HITECH Act, state breach notification laws
  • Government: FedRAMP, FISMA, agency-specific requirements
  • International: Local data protection and privacy regulations

Incident Types and Response Considerations

Data Breach Incidents:

  • Immediate containment and access revocation
  • Evidence preservation and forensic analysis
  • Regulatory notification requirements
  • Customer and stakeholder communication
  • Credit monitoring and remediation services

Malware and Ransomware:

  • System isolation and containment
  • Malware analysis and eradication
  • Backup validation and recovery
  • Payment consideration and negotiation
  • System hardening and prevention measures

Insider Threats:

  • Discrete investigation and evidence collection
  • HR and legal coordination
  • Access monitoring and restriction
  • Behavioral analysis and profiling
  • Policy and control improvements

DDoS Attacks:

  • Traffic analysis and filtering
  • Capacity scaling and load balancing
  • ISP and CDN coordination
  • Business continuity activation
  • Attack attribution and response

Supply Chain Compromises:

  • Vendor assessment and communication
  • System isolation and analysis
  • Third-party coordination and response
  • Contract and SLA enforcement
  • Alternative supplier activation

Regulatory and Compliance Considerations

Notification Requirements:

  • GDPR: 72-hour breach notification to authorities
  • HIPAA: 60-day breach notification to HHS
  • PCI DSS: Immediate notification to card brands
  • State Laws: Various notification timelines and requirements

Evidence Handling:

  • Chain of Custody: Maintain proper evidence handling procedures
  • Legal Hold: Preserve relevant data and communications
  • Forensic Standards: Follow industry-standard forensic practices
  • Expert Testimony: Prepare for potential legal proceedings

Regulatory Coordination:

  • Law Enforcement: Coordinate with appropriate agencies
  • Regulators: Communicate with relevant regulatory bodies
  • Industry Groups: Share threat intelligence and best practices
  • Legal Counsel: Involve legal experts in response decisions

Related Resources

Table of contents

Copyright © 2025 Cloudvisor. Distributed under the MIT license.

Powered by Just the Docs, a documentation theme for Jekyll.